How 11 New York City Babies Contracted Herpes Through Circumcision

An ultra-Orthodox Jewish circumcision ritual is found to cause neonatal herpes infections in newborns in New York City, prompting health officials to encourage parents to consider the health risks of the practice.

  • Share
  • Read Later
P Deliss / Getty Images

The report is sure to reignite a long-simmering debate over public health and religious liberties: the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reported on Thursday that 11 baby boys in New York City were infected with herpes between Nov. 2000 and Dec. 2011 following an ultra-Orthodox Jewish circumcision ritual called metzitzah b’peh — or oral suction — in which the mohel puts his mouth directly on the newborn’s circumcised penis and sucks away the blood.

Ten of the babies were hospitalized, at least two developed brain damage and two died, according to the New York City health department. In 2005, New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg asked rabbis throughout the city to move away from performing metzitzah b’peh — and also issued an open letter [PDF] to the Jewish community warning of the health risks — but they refused claiming the practice was safe.

(MORE: Battle of the Bris: A Move to Outlaw Circumcision in San Francisco)

According to the CDC report, the investigation into circumcision-related herpes infections in newborns began in 2004 when New York City’s Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH) was notified of twin boys who had contracted herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1, the type that causes cold sores and is usually transmitted orally) following circumcision with metzitzah b’peh; one twin died. Both twins were circumcised by the same mohel, whom the CDC report refers to as “mohel A.”

During the investigation, the DOHMH learned of another 2003 case of neonatal HSV-1 infection after circumcision, also involving mohel A. In all three cases, the babies’ mothers and the hospital staff who cared for the infants had no history of herpes infection. When mohel A was tested about three months after the 2004 circumcisions, he showed antibodies to HSV in his blood, but was not found to be actively shedding the virus.

In all three cases, the babies developed lesions or vesicles in their genital areas about 8 to 10 days after their ritual circumcision; the timing and location of the babies’ symptoms suggest that the infections were introduced during circumcision, the CDC reports. The health officials’ investigation further uncovered eight other similar cases through Dec. 2011 in New York City, bringing the total to 11.

(MORE: Circumcision: The Surgery that May Lower Prostate-Cancer Risk)

About 85% of all neonatal HSV infections (including HSV-2, which causes genital herpes) are transmitted during delivery from an infected mother, 5% of infections are congenital and 10% are acquired after birth, usually from adult caregivers. HSV-1 is extremely common in the adult population — infecting some 73% of New York City adults over 20 — but the CDC report finds that HSV-1 infection in baby boys is rare, with about three cases a year on average in New York City.

Based on the overall incidence of neonatal HSV infections, total birth statistics and estimates of boys being circumcised with direct oral-genital suction (about 3,564 a year in New York City), health officials estimate that the risk of HSV infection in baby boys after metzitzah b’peh is 3.4 times greater than in boys who aren’t exposed to oral suction. Overall, the risk of herpes infection following metzitzah b’peh was 24.4 per 100,000 baby boys between April 2006 and Dec. 2011, the CDC estimates.

The authors of the CDC report write:

Circumcision is a surgical procedure that can transmit infection if not performed under sterile conditions. Oral contact with an open wound in a neonate risks transmission of HSV and other pathogens. Professionals advising parents and parents choosing Jewish ritual circumcision should be aware of this risk, and direct orogenital suction should be avoided.

New York City Health Commissioner Dr. Thomas Farley also released a statement [PDF] urging that metzitzah b’peh not be performed. The health department also announced that several New York City hospitals, including those serving Hasidic Jewish communities, have agreed to distribute a brochure [PDF] describing the herpes risk to infants and advising parents considering out-of-hospital Jewish circumcision to ask the mohel before the bris whether he practices metzitzah b’peh. If so, parents can talk to their health-care providers and consider other options for circumcision.

“There is no safe way to perform oral suction on any open wound in a newborn,” Farley said. “Parents considering ritual Jewish circumcision need to know that circumcision should only be performed under sterile conditions, like any other procedures that create open cuts, whether by mohelim or medical professionals.”

(MORE: CDC: Why Are U.S. Circumcision Rates Declining?)

The following New York City hospitals will be distributing the brochure:

  • All HHC facilities
  • Maimonides
  • NYU-Langone
  • North Shore LIJ
  • Staten Island University
  • Lenox Hill
  • New York Methodist
  • New York Presbyterian
  • Forest Hills

During the course of the DOHMH investigation, health officials determined that four mohelim were confirmed to be involved in seven of the herpes cases. In two of those cases (involving the same mohel who circumcised two brothers three years apart), parents declined to reveal the identify of the practitioner, so it’s not clear whether he was the same mohel involved in any of the other cases. Therefore, the total number of mohelim involved in the 11 cases can’t be determined, but the investigators presume it is at least three and not more than eight.

(MORE: Study: Women with Circumcised Partners May Have Lower HPV Risk)

None of the mohelim are identified by name in the current CDC report. However, previous news accounts of neonatal herpes infections following ritual Jewish circumcision and oral suction in 2003 and 2004 identified Rabbi Yitzchock Fischer as the mohel. He was subsequently banned from performing the ritual in New York City.

“We’re not oblivious to what’s going on,” Rabbi David Zwiebel, executive vice president of Agudath Israel of America, told the New York Times in March, regarding the health risks surrounding metzitzah b’peh. He added: “The worst thing that could happen is if the authorities regulate this practice, then it could go underground. … I think the practice would continue, but there could be significant difficulty in gathering evidence.”

The CDC report is published in the agency’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report.

MORE: What’s a Bris? L.A. Hospital Launches Workshop for Jewish Parents-to-Be

16 comments
CollinsCool
CollinsCool

i want to say a big thank to dr.ozalla for helping me i was herpes patient for good four years i was loosing hope on myself my girlfriend ran away from me because of my situation one day i was online and i met a comment on how dr.ozalla help her i was interested then i quickly emailed him and he told me everything i need to do before i will be cured which i actually did but today am cured that is why i want you to join me thank dr ozalla for saving my life if you need help please contact him email dr.ozallaspellhome@outlook.com

ElenaHomson
ElenaHomson

                HOW TO CURE HERPES AND OTHER DISEASE


My name is elena homson i am from USA, I am here to give my testimony about a doctor who helped me in my life. I 


was infected with HERPES in 2014, i went to many hospitals for cure but there was no solution, so I was thinking 


how can I get a solution out so that my body can be okay. One day I was in the river side thinking where I can 


go to get solution. so a lady walked to me her name is kutrila telling me why am I so sad and i open up all to 


her telling her my problem,that i have herpes genital  she told me that she can help me out, she introduce me to 


a doctor who uses herbal medication to cure HERPES and gave me his email, so i mail him. He told me all the 


things I need to do and also give me instructions to take, which I followed properly. Before I knew what is 


happening after two weeks the HERPES that was in my body got vanished . so if you are you are having herpes or 


any kind of disease listed below and you also want cure, you can also email him at: 


doctoromoleherbalhome@gmail.com.


if you are having any type of this disease or infection kindly email doctor omole for cure


1 mouth cancer                            

2 skin cancer,

3 HIV,

4 cellulite,

5 chickenpox,

6 cold sore,

7 diaper rash,

8 fifth disease,

9 herpes simplex,

10 hand-foot mouth disease,

11 genital warts,

12 jock itch,

13 lupus,

14 nail problem,

15 impetigo,

16 nail infection,

17 Lyme disease,

18 yeast infection,

19 atopic dermatitis,warts,thrush,

20 athletes foot,


kindly email doctor omole for you own cure if you have any disease listed above via 


doctoromoleherbalhome@gmail.com


JoffreAlice
JoffreAlice

I am Miss Alice 24yrs old, my childhood herpes returned. It started with itchy chin, then on to other areas of the body it was buttocks, groin, etc. I tried everything and anything that i read about like creams, ointments, oils, homeopathic remedies. Though each provided some relief, I was still plagued by the virus. Then i saw testimony of how Dr. Henry cured herpes simplex virus and i contacted him to happened upon my cure. Despite the medical doctor says there is no cure, this herbalist proof that they are wrong. Dr. Henry a wonderful herbalist and he's caring and empathetic, doing everything he can to help and work for you. You can write to him through his email dr.henryherpescure@gmail.com. This testimonial serves as an expression of my gratitude.

ValdeVenor
ValdeVenor

Hi
   I slept with my girlfriend who was away for a longtime and she didn’t tell me that she had herpes. I had so much heart broken after knowing that I have contacted genital herpes. I just committed one sin and I'm gone forever. Until i read of Dr. Maccus online and i contacted him for help, he give me all the procedure in which i followed and take the herbal medicine as instructed and he told me to go for test. To my greatest joy was that the virus was totally flushed out of my system, I pray that God should strengthen Dr. Maccus for taking this disease away from my body.
    Honestly in my heart i want to sincerely thank Dr. Maccus for making normal again and to all those who are in pain because of this disease don't be discourage. I pray that he that did it for me will also do it for you, you can contact him with this email address dr.maccusherpescure@gmail.com

ScottWilson
ScottWilson

Dr. Dan God will continue to bless you more abundantly, for the good works you are doing in peoples life, I will keep on testifying about your good work, I was healed from HERPES VIRUS through the help of Dr Dan. I saw a blog on how Dr Dan known as "LORD SPIRITUAL" cured people with his herbal treatment, i did not believe but i just decided to give him a try, I contacted him and he prepare the herbs for me which i took, after taking it, he told me to go for check up, could you believe that i was confirm herpes negative after the test, and i went to a different hospital and it was also negative, i am so happy. If you have any problem or you are also infected with any disease, kindly contact him now with his Email: LORDSPIRITUAL@OUTLOOK.COM or call him on +2347051757649 you can also reach me for more information scottwilson4luv@gmail.com

ValdeVenor
ValdeVenor

Hi
   I slept with my girlfriend who was away for a longtime and she didn’t tell me that she had herpes. I had so much heart broken after knowing that I have contacted genital herpes. I just committed one sin and I'm gone forever. Until i read of Dr. Maccus online and i contacted him for help, he give me all the procedure in which i followed and take the herbal medicine as instructed and he told me to go for test. To my greatest joy was that the virus was totally flushed out of my system, I pray that God should strengthen Dr. Maccus for taking this disease away from my body.
    Honestly in my heart i want to sincerely thank Dr. Maccus for making normal again and to all those who are in pain because of this disease don't be discourage. I pray that he that did it for me will also do it for you, you can contact him with this email address dr.maccusherpescure@gmail.com

HarbertMichelle
HarbertMichelle

Hi,
My name is Harbert Michelle, six months ago I had sex with the third guy in my life whom i was about to marry and now I have herpes. I couldn’t believe it because he wasn’t a random guy, he’s the closet guy I’ve had as a boyfriend, but it has been a never ending nightmare since. I’ve always believed in GOD and have asked him for forgiveness which is ironic.
   I felt like killing myself with the taught of having a husband and family will be quite difficult and i felt like I’m not really in the room when people are talking. I didn’t know what to do and pretty much cry and pray every day to God for help and looking at my family with so much love and feeling that i have disappointed them even though they don’t know. Until God lead me to DR. HARRY online who promised to help me cure my disease through herbals. At first i didn't believe him, but to my greatest surprise i was cured completely by herbals, which medical doctor also verified that i was cured. Special thanks to DR. HARRY.
   Don't be discourage because he that did it for me will also do it for you and you can contact him through his email address dr.harryherpescentre@gmail.com

olu
olu

My name is Carol Anderson, I am here to give my testimony about a doctor who helped me in my life. I was infected with HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS in 2010, i went to many hospitals for cure but there was no solution, so I was thinking how can I get a solution out so that my body can be okay. One day I was in the river side thinking where I can go to get solution. so a lady walked to me telling me why am I so sad and i open up all to her telling her my problem, she told me that she can help me out, she introduce me to a doctor who uses herbal medication to cure HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS and gave me his email, so i mail him. He told me all the things I need to do and also give me instructions to take, which I followed properly. Before I knew what is happening after two weeks the HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS that was in my body got vanished . so if you are also heart broken and also need a help, you can also email him at: makutaherbaltemple@gmail.com

SimranMendy
SimranMendy

Greetings to the general public, Am Simran Mendy i want to inform the public how i was cured of HERPES Simplex Virus by a Doctor called Harrison.i visited different hospital but they gave me list of drugs like Famvir, Zovirax, and Valtrex which is very expensive to treat the symptoms and never cured me. I was browsing through the Internet searching for remedy on HERPES and i saw comment of people talking about how Doctor Harrison cured them. I Was scared because i never believed in the Internet but i was convince to give him a try because i was having no hope of been cured of HERPES so i decided to contact him on his email that was listed on the comment (sacredspelltemple@hotmail.com ) i searched his email on net and i saw a lot of people testifying about his goodness. when i contacted him he gave me hope and send a Herbal medicine to me that i took and it seriously worked for me, am a free person now without problem, my HERPES result came out negative. I pray for you Dr Harrison God will give you everlasting life, you shall not die before your time for being a sincere and great men. Am so happy, you can also contact him if you have any problem Email: SACREDSPELLTEMPLE@HOTMAIL.COM.

or add him on whatapp +2348079540032. you can contact me for more information +1989-541-7345 or email me on simranmendy@gmail.com...

mackenzieamanda11
mackenzieamanda11

I can stop writing about him he that give me light to enjoy my life again I was very sick all this year without no one can be about to cure me from this herpes disease the only man who help me is dr.abulumen the man that always keep his promise when I get his email on internet see people writing about his good work and I was having same problem I quickly contact him for help also because I was holpness I never believe he really have cure to this disease untill he really show me the true him i write this man my problem and he inform me what I need to do I did it without any complain this man work on my problem and he called me the nextday to go for test and I found out I was cured thanks dr.abulumen for your work you can contact him now if you need his help  DR.ABULUMENSPELLHOME@GMAIL.COM  OR DR.ABULUMENSPIRITUALTEMPLE@YAHOO.COM  or just called him  +2348167022540

mackenzieamanda11
mackenzieamanda11

What  a miracle am really cured from this sickness, I will forever give you thanks dr.abulumen for your help I was in pain for good 4year I was have this herpes sickness I was tried of my life because of the pain I was passing through I hv search for help just last 3month ago my friend from Facebook inform me about this Africa man who can cure me from this sickness and which he did,my friend give me his number to call him and explain my problem to him which I did and the man need to have my details and will decide to use email to complete our communication I send all he needed for the cure and he did according to the way he inform me am very grateful to tell you friend about my story if you need his help you can email him now DR.ABULUMENSPELLHOME@GMAIL.COM  OR DR.ABULUMENSPIRITUALTEMPLE@YAHOO.COM  or just called him  +2348167022540

JuanO.Lawson
JuanO.Lawson

WHEN GOD GAVE ABRAM CIRCUMSION, at no time did he have the men suck the blood out of the penis of anyone. I am sure God would have considered such behavior sexual perversion. NO WONDERR THOSE MALE BABIES ARE BEING INFECTED--BY THESE PERVERTED RELIGIOUS LEADERS. The Catholic Church seemingly is not alone with with regard to sexual abuse of children.

samolog
samolog

A grown man sucks on a baby boy's penis??!!! That is the most disgusting, perverse thing. How to you explain to your child that you wanted his genitals to be mutilated for an invisible man in the sky who demanded through his scripture that another man mutilate his genitals and suck on his penis? Oh and that he got an incurable STD for it as well. Disgusting.

Cloudnine
Cloudnine

circumcision is bad for children, bad for society. No disease, no consent, no circumcision.

IAMDreO
IAMDreO

@DessyO_ lmao the stuff is makin u crazy about the penis

pozgroup
pozgroup

I do not think circumcision is useful as I can see more and more new members at HerpesDatingNYC.c0m, a dating and support community for people with herpes in New York.