U.S. Panel Warns Hormone Replacement Therapy Is Too Risky

A government group is advising women to use hormone replacement therapy (HRT) to treat symptoms of menopause for only short periods of time

  • Share
  • Read Later
Christopher Robbins / Getty Images

A government group is advising women to use hormone replacement therapy (HRT) to treat symptoms of menopause for only short periods of time.

The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF), an independent group of health experts convened at the request of Congress, first hinted that HRT may be too risky for long term use in 2005. At that time, after reviewing the available data, the task force warned women against relying on HRT to prevent chronic conditions like heart disease and dementia. Some earlier studies had suggested that the supplemental hormones that women take to relieve night sweats and hot flashes associated with menopause could also protect the heart and brain from aging-related decline.

But use of hormone therapy declined after a 2002  Women’s Health Initiative (WHI) study found little difference in rates of heart disease among women who used HRT and those who did not. Instead, it reported HRT may increase the risks of heart disease and breast cancer.

(MORE: Hormone Replacement Therapy After Menopause: What Women Need to Know)

In its most recent analysis, published online in the Annals of Internal Medicine, the USPSTF confirmed its previous findings that the risk of HRT outweigh its potential benefits. The task force made its final recommendation based on a review of 51 additional studies published since 2002. Overall, the data show that HRT, which combines estrogen and progestin, is linked to increased risk of stroke, blood clots, gallbladder disease, urinary incontinence, dementia and breast cancer. Even among women who have had a hysterectomy, and therefore only need to take estrogen and not progestin to protect endometrial tissue, the risks remained significant.

The only benefits of HRT the USPSTF found outside of relieving menopause symptoms was a lower risk of fractures. But the risks far outweighed this improvement, the task force concluded.  So for women at average-risk of heart disease or breast cancer, which make up the majority of those who might take HRT during menopause menopause, the panel recommends against long-term use of the hormones. For those who need immediate relief of menopausal symptoms, however, short term use of the hormones can be helpful and relatively safe. That practice is supported by a recent study published in the British Medical Journal that found estrogen-only hormone therapy shortly after menopause doesn’t result in an increase in heart risks.

(MORE: Estrogen After Menopause Lowers Breast Cancer Risk for Some Women)

Still, this recommendation isn’t likely to be the final word on HRT. The task force says more research is needed on the use of HRT among women who are transitioning through menopause, and the effects the hormones can have on women of different ages. They note that those involved in the WHI trial that found no long term benefits were on average 64 years old, which, the panel says, is “largely past the point of menopause onset.”

For now, major health organizations like the American Heart Association, the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and the American Academy of Family Physicians also recommend against long-term HRT use in postmenopausal women to treat conditions other than menopausal symptoms.

(MORE: Making Sense of Hormone Therapy After Menopause)

“I agree with the USPSTF guidelines that hormone therapy should not be used for chronic disease prevention,” Dr. JoAnn E. Manson, chief of the division of preventive medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston told WebMD. “The pendulum has swung to the more appropriate place of hormone therapy reserved for the treatment of menopausal symptoms.”

3 comments
Loribean
Loribean

ESTROGEN SAVES LIVES!!! I can honestly say that HRT SAVED MY LIFE.  I was 47 and my cycle sporadic, I was bipolar, sleepless, my blood pressure had soared to 160/100, I had heart palps, was getting trouble with co-workers and tried to run my sister over with my car due to a bout of uncontrollable rage (what I lovingly refer to as my Jerry Springer moment in history), this started me on a SHAME SPIRAL of sickness and guilt, I became suicidal and sick or being sick and tired.  NOT ONE DOCTOR asked me if it was my hormones! even my endo at a famous teaching hospital!  I have thyroid issues.  Anyways, I realized that it was hormone imbalacne on my own thank you very much primary care provider that had known me for 20 years! thanks for offering my anti-psychotics, anti-depressents, cardiac meds, sleeping pills....oh yeah those are WAY SAFER than a naturally occuring substance in my body!  I should have run my docs over!  I demanded a transdermal patch and progesterone cream.  I cut the patch in HALF it's only .025mg!  thats it!!  and I AM CURED!!! I love my life, I am happy, productive, I don;t cry and pee myself every five minutes.  I am APPALLED that women are not getting the helpo they need from estrogen therapy.  they call it therapy for a reason!!  I am so happy my BP is down to 117/70.  No PVC's.  tons of energy to excercise...tell me that it's not healthy now!  strong bones and heart, muscles, sleeing like a baby...I famous law professor in my town just killed herself at 48.  same age as me.  All of the reports and articles talked about how she had gone to a dark place over the past year...from a mother or two super achiever to suicide?  that spells hormones to me! NOT ONE ARTICLE in our papers mentioned hormones...all about depression and mental illness.  I wish I wish I wish she had been as lucky as me (tears).  BRAVO estrogen.  I will take you until I'm 80 and bring on the breast cancer and stroke....I do not even care,.  I eat right (vegan) hike every day do not drink do not smoke never take anything except for supplements (lets talk Vitamin D very imp too!) and I feel healthier than ever thanks to my teeny weeny estrogen dose!  thank you god and evil pharmeceutical companies!

AlmaMott
AlmaMott

HRT for men (aka hormone replacement therapy) is growing in popularity. Some might wonder why so many men are interested in boosting their hormone levels. Once you gain a clearer insight into what occurs when hormone levels drop, you quickly realize why it is so valuable to maintain these levels. http://www.ageexperts.net/

HeshamMostafa
HeshamMostafa

It's an authentic discovery in cancer exploration. A medical study disclosed that they managed to decrease 3-year fatality rate in people with metastatic cancer malignancy by over 5 times. There is nothing identical to this result in the whole cancer investigation. I repeat 5 times fewer people deceased in three years when they utilized one supplementary therapy. The process was based on this process utilized by about 200 Russian clinical doctors, and the goal of the treatment is to improve oxygen concentrations in body tissues employing the famous Buteyko respiration method. These exciting results are documented and all specifics of their treatment method are spelled out in the Kindle eBook from Amazon “Doctors Who Cure Cancer”: <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Doctors-Cure-Cancer-Books-ebook/dp/B007IZZ4AQ/">Cancer books</a> by Dr. Artour Rakhimov. When you meet a person with a cancer tumor, remember to share!