Charlie Sheen’s public meltdown–media blitz continues, with riveting interviews aired on morning shows on NBC and ABC; a volatile, rambling conversation streamed on TMZ.com; and a more restrained appearance on CNN’s Piers Morgan Tonight.
Also on Monday, Feb. 28: Sheen threatened legal action against his employers, Warner Bros. (which, like TIME, is a unit of Time Warner) and CBS, which on Feb. 25 canceled the production of Sheen’s sitcom Two and a Half Men; his longtime manager, Stan Rosenfield, resigned; and the embattled actor dropped gems like, “Sorry my life is so much more bitchin’ than yours. I planned it that way,” and “I am on a drug. It’s called Charlie Sheen. It’s not available because if you try it once, you will die. Your face will melt off, and your children will weep over your exploded body.”
(More on TIME.com: “Can You Use Crack ‘Socially’? Addiction Myth Watch: Charlie Sheen Edition”)
His ranting behavior has led people to question whether the actor is still on drugs and denying an addiction. Or whether he is exhibiting manic symptoms of bipolar disorder. Or some combination of the two. Sheen’s negative drug test suggests that addiction is unlikely to be his only problem.
Although it isn’t possible to diagnose patients at a distance, Sheen’s case illustrates why it can be difficult for experts to distinguish among symptoms of a cocaine or meth high, drug withdrawal and bipolar mania. Here is a breakdown of the key characteristics that Sheen has displayed, and what they may mean:
Denial. Most people think of addiction when they hear the word denial, but the truth is that denial is not always seen in addiction. What’s more, it’s a common phase of reaction to many life experiences, including physical and psychiatric illness. For example, when many people learn of a cancer diagnosis or the death of a loved one, a common response is, “No, I can’t believe it. That can’t be true.”
(More on TIME.com: See the top 10 celebrity meltdowns.)
In addiction and mental illness, denial most commonly appears when the patient is confronted. The same addict who admits to shooting drugs when willingly at a needle exchange will often deny using to someone who’s trying to get that person into rehab. In the case of a person with a mental disorder like, say, bipolar disorder, he or she will often admit to having symptoms like racing thoughts when it’s not being framed as evidence of a mental illness — or, as Sheen put it on TMZ.com, “I don’t have burnout of my gearbox. I just go.”
However, when confronted by ABC’s Andrea Canning about being bipolar, he dismissed the suggestion, saying, “I’m bi-winning … If I’m bipolar, aren’t there moments where a guy, like, crashes and is lying in the corner, like, ‘Oh my God, it’s all my mom’s fault’? Shut up.”
This is why a skillful counselor facing a patient like Sheen won’t try to “confront denial.” Instead, he or she will “roll with resistance” and work to discuss any life problems that the patient agrees may be problematic. If someone with addiction or bipolar disorder believes that a professional is genuinely trying to help — and not attempting to control him or force him to conform to society’s demands — denial tends to slip away.
Some might argue that Sheen’s resistance to — or even hatred of — 12-step recovery programs and inpatient treatment could be construed as addictive denial. But one size doesn’t fit all in the treatment of disorders, and for some patients, being forced into the 12-step approach can be counterproductive. Simply wanting treatment choice is not a sign of a disease.
(More on TIME.com: “Before Charlie: The Five Most Bizarre Celeb Interviews”)
“Everyone’s approaching [Sheen] as though he’s on drugs,” says Dr. Alex DeLuca, a former chief of the Smithers Addiction Research and Treatment Center. “It isn’t the first thing that would come to my mind, especially when he’s exhibiting symptoms off the substances. You can’t blame the drug if he doesn’t have it in him.”
Grandiosity and narcissism. Sheen has expressed a sense of superiority in many interviews over the past few weeks, telling the Alex Jones radio show, for example, “News flash: I am special, and I will never be one of you.”
In the ABC interview, Sheen responded to a question about being perceived as “erratic” by saying, “You borrow my brain for five seconds and just be like, Dude, can’t handle it, unplug this bastard because yeah, it fires in a way that is maybe not from this particular terrestrial realm.” He added, “I’m tired of pretending like I’m not special.”
Many people think grandiosity is a sign of drug abuse, but experts say it may more likely signal mania. “Whether someone views his behavior as grandiose would be a matter of personal opinion, but certainly there are lots of people who are grandiose who do not have any addictions and a lot of people with addiction who are not at all grandiose,” says A. Thomas Horvath, author of Sex, Drugs, Gambling & Chocolate: A Workbook for Overcoming Addictions and president of the Practical Recovery addiction-treatment service in California. “The distinction between high energy and bright mood and a manic episode can be tricky particularly if someone’s right in the border region.”
Like grandiosity, the narcissistic traits that have been exhibited by Sheen over the past few weeks — for example, allowing his behavior to result in a job loss for the dozens of people who make a living on his multimillion-dollar show — are neither specific to addiction nor necessary for it. “There’s no single addictive personality,” says Horvath. “Some traits, like impulsivity and grandiosity or depression or anxiety, are found in a subset of [addicted people]. But the idea that you could identify a particular personality type and say this person will develop addiction: there’s no evidence to support that.”
(More on TIME.com: “Interview with the Warlock: Charlie Sheen Puts On Another Show”)
Anger and irritability. When ABC’s Canning confronted Sheen about his apparent anger toward his former bosses, he was quick to reframe it as “passion.” Irritability can be a symptom of mania, and anger appears in addicts, but similar to characteristics like narcissism, grandiosity and denial, they are not specific to or necessary for either addiction or mania.
“In a manic episode, the mood can be elevated or expansive or irritable,” says Horvath. “When someone is highly irritable, that could be considered one way of being manic.” But both Horvath and DeLuca note that Sheen’s situation could legitimately make anyone irritable. “An average person being treated that way might well be in some manner upset,” says Horvath, suggesting that context matters when considering irritability as part of a diagnosis.
Pressured speech. People who are either high on stimulants or experiencing a manic episode may exhibit a phenomenon known as pressured speech in which words seem to flow much faster and with less inhibition than would be normal. Again, consider Sheen’s response to the question about being angry: “You borrow my brain for five seconds and just be like, Dude, can’t handle it, unplug this bastard because yeah, it fires in a way that is maybe not from this particular terrestrial realm.”
Likewise, his full response to being asked directly about bipolar disorder seemed to escape his lips with little self-censorship: “What does that mean? Wow. And then what? What’s the cure? Medicine? Make me like them? Not gonna happen. I’m bi-winning. I win here, and I win there. Now what? If I’m bipolar, aren’t there moments where a guy, like, crashes and is lying in the corner, like, ‘Oh my God, it’s all my mom’s fault’? Shut up. Shut up. Stop, move forward.”
But is this bipolar, addiction or both disorders? The determination may be complicated by one final factor:
Withdrawal. During the first few days of abstinence — or sometimes the first weeks or months, depending on the substance and the length of the addiction — many people suffer extreme mood swings. That makes a firm psychiatric diagnosis nearly impossible in patients who have only recently quit drugs.
(More on TIME.com: See how being a jerk shortens your life.)
“You try to detox them so you see what’s what,” says DeLuca. “Depending on what you know about their history, you may have a good guess. If you don’t know this person and don’t know their history, clearing the decks [through drug abstinence] is not a bad idea. Over the course of detox, you can get a better psychiatric evaluation.”
DeLuca notes, however, that not all medication is off-limits during detox; prescription drugs may be necessary to help keep people comfortable enough to stay in treatment. But until someone has been free from illegal drugs for at least a few weeks, it may not be clear whether his or her erratic behavior indicates withdrawal or a serious psychiatric problem.
In many cases, it may be both. According to a 2010 paper published in the New York Academy of Sciences, bipolar disorder is more likely than any other psychiatric disorder to be accompanied by substance-misuse problems. About 61% of people with bipolar I — the classic form of the disorder in which patients swing from manic highs to depressive lows — also have an addiction. In people with the milder bipolar II, the rate of addiction is 48%. In general, at least half of people who suffer from addiction also have a coexisting psychiatric disorder.
Whatever Sheen’s particular problems are, a diagnosis is impossible without further evaluation and monitoring. Like any patient, Sheen needs to be evaluated “by a professional who can assess all aspects of mental health, not just the addiction,” says Horvath. “If they have their addiction spectacles on, that’s all they can see, but human beings are complex and rarely have just one problem.”
“I hope Mr. Sheen finds someone skilled he can trust and work with,” says DeLuca.
The Key to Health, Wealth and Success: Self-Control